More on my recent trip to California... The primary reason for my visit was to sell a patent I was awarded a few years ago. In my earlier post I mentioned that I visited Google. Google wasn't the buyer of the patent... or to be precise, I don't know who the buyer was, as it was kept confidential. I am moderately happy with the sale, for several reasons. The sale price was more than twice the highest previous offer. I had had the patent for several years and hadn't had much serious licensing interest (although admittedly I had spent little time actively looking for licensees). It is a business model patent, which the courts have not been very keen on recently. And it probably would've cost a couple million to defend against any infringers (although I'm not aware of any infringers). The claims are extremely broad, which is great, but as with any patent there's no guarantee that they'd hold up in court.
The patent is for what I think is a truly revolutionary idea for streamlining online transactions. It's not obvious that the idea will work; on the surface it seems like it probably wouldn't work, but after a little thought most people I've talked to agree that it has some chance of working. The key point is that if it does work, it could be truly huge. Critically, for the idea to be successful it would require massive scale, on the order of millions of transactions a month. The potential buyer might be able to reach this level, but I was pretty sure that I couldn't. I do hope that the buyer makes the idea work. If they use it to build the next ebay or amazon, I would be very satisfied both that my idea was implemented on a large scale and that it resulted in increased efficiencies for the world's transactions, and only slightly jealous and regretful that I wasn't the one who made it happen.
I'm glad I went through the process of patenting my invention. The patent didn't take very long for me to put together, so on a per hour basis it netted me more per hour than I get in my day job. Although the process was an interesting one to go through once, I don't have any plans to patent any of the other ideas bouncing around in my head. The fun part was coming up with the idea and then trying to figure out the details of how it might work. The writing of the claims required a part of my brain I had never used before, and reminded me why I'm glad I'm not a lawyer. Working with (against?) the patent office to get the paperwork completed and to persuade the examiner that the claims should be approved was pretty unpleasant and could've only partially been outsourced to a patent lawyer. Like my experiences with the isolation tank, skydiving, and drugs, it belongs on my list of things worth doing once or twice but not making a habit of.
The patent is for what I think is a truly revolutionary idea for streamlining online transactions. It's not obvious that the idea will work; on the surface it seems like it probably wouldn't work, but after a little thought most people I've talked to agree that it has some chance of working. The key point is that if it does work, it could be truly huge. Critically, for the idea to be successful it would require massive scale, on the order of millions of transactions a month. The potential buyer might be able to reach this level, but I was pretty sure that I couldn't. I do hope that the buyer makes the idea work. If they use it to build the next ebay or amazon, I would be very satisfied both that my idea was implemented on a large scale and that it resulted in increased efficiencies for the world's transactions, and only slightly jealous and regretful that I wasn't the one who made it happen.
I'm glad I went through the process of patenting my invention. The patent didn't take very long for me to put together, so on a per hour basis it netted me more per hour than I get in my day job. Although the process was an interesting one to go through once, I don't have any plans to patent any of the other ideas bouncing around in my head. The fun part was coming up with the idea and then trying to figure out the details of how it might work. The writing of the claims required a part of my brain I had never used before, and reminded me why I'm glad I'm not a lawyer. Working with (against?) the patent office to get the paperwork completed and to persuade the examiner that the claims should be approved was pretty unpleasant and could've only partially been outsourced to a patent lawyer. Like my experiences with the isolation tank, skydiving, and drugs, it belongs on my list of things worth doing once or twice but not making a habit of.











